The Rev. Irving Parrott 1924-1926
No Photo the Rev. F. W. Heldstab 1926-1931
No Photo the Rev. C. A. Lemon 1931 [Interim]
The Rev. Paul Haskell-Clark 1931-1953
No Photo the Rev. Erling Edwardsen [Interim]
The Rev. Allinson Amstutz 1954-1967
The Rev. Frederic McNeil 1967-1970
No Photo Dr. John Figley [Interim]
The Rev. A. D. William Collins 1971-1999
The Rev. James Brammer 1999-July 16, 2000 [Interim]
The Rev. Dr. Richard Loerop July 17, 2000 – August 31st 2005
The Revs. Ron Houk and Wayne Buskerk
2005-2007
Pastor Brett Spalding 2007-2009
Wayne Buskerk Interim November 2009-August 28 2011
Reverend Kathleen Dain September 2011 – 2012
Reverend John Brown December 2012